Chronicle

Big Cartel vs Modalyst

Big Cartel starts at $15/mo across 3 plans. Modalyst starts at $35/mo across 3 plans.

Big Cartel
E-commerce
3 plans
$0 Gold $15 Platinum $30 Diamond $0 Gold $15 Platinum $30 Diamond
From $15$15/moFree tier
Modalyst
E-commerce
3 plans
$0 Hobby $35 Start Up $90 Pro $0 Hobby $30 Start Up $67 Pro
From $35$30/moFree tier
Big Cartel's cheapest paid plan costs $15/mo, $20 less than Modalyst at $35/mo. Both offer a free tier.

Plan by plan

TierBig CartelModalyst
01Gold
$0$0
Hobby
$0$0
02Platinum
$15$15 /mo
Start Up
$35$30 /mo
03Diamond
$30$30 /mo
Pro
$90$67 /mo

Beyond price: what you get

Big CartelModalyst
Entry plan includesNot listedStart Up
  • 250 product limit
Watch out forNot listedNot listed

Plans are listed in each vendor's own order. Prices in USD; confirm on the vendor's site before buying.

Big Cartel vs Modalyst: how the pricing differs

Big Cartel: Online store builder for artists and makers. Modalyst: Modalyst is a dropshipping product sourcing app for ecommerce stores.

Big Cartel

Big Cartel lists 3 plans, priced at a flat rate. There is a free plan, Gold. The cheapest paid plan is Platinum at $15 a month. The most expensive published plan is Diamond at $30 a month.

Modalyst

Modalyst lists 3 plans, priced at a flat rate. There is a free plan, Hobby. The cheapest paid plan is Start Up at $35 a month per store. The most expensive published plan is Pro at $90 a month. Paying yearly saves up to 26% compared with monthly billing.

Which one costs less for you

  • If the entry price matters most, Big Cartel is cheaper to start.

Price history

We have no recorded price changes for Big Cartel yet. We have no recorded price changes for Modalyst yet. Full timelines are on the Big Cartel and Modalyst pages.

Where these numbers come from

Every figure on this page was read from the vendor's own pricing page: bigcartel.com (checked 2026-11-15) and modalyst.co (checked 2026-11-19). Prices are list prices in the vendor's published currency, before tax. We don't estimate or round, and no vendor pays to appear here or to change how it's shown. How we check prices.

Questions

Is Big Cartel cheaper than Modalyst?

Big Cartel's cheapest paid plan costs $15/mo, $20 less than Modalyst at $35/mo. Both offer a free tier.

Does Big Cartel or Modalyst have a free plan?

Both do: Big Cartel Gold and Modalyst Hobby.

When were these prices checked?

Big Cartel on 2026-11-15 and Modalyst on 2026-11-19, from each vendor's official pricing page.